Define the material before negotiating the rights
Company archives rarely contain only one type of material. Original designs, customer documents, libraries and inherited projects may sit together. A useful scope might identify particular historical product ranges, project periods or approved file groups, rather than referring loosely to “all CAD data”.
Supporting records need the same clarity. Permission relating to models does not automatically include BOMs, engineering correspondence or inspection reports. The provenance guide helps distinguish those sources before they are treated as a single licensable collection.
Name the intended uses and the recipients
Training, evaluation and the creation of derived engineering tasks are different activities. The agreement should identify which are intended. It should also distinguish a partner preparing the records from an organisation receiving them for an agreed AI use.
Further distribution, sublicensing and publication need explicit consideration. If restrictions on competitor access are important, they belong in the agreement. Anonymisation or an NDA does not, by itself, create those restrictions.
| Question | What needs a clear answer |
|---|---|
Material |
Which projects, file groups and revisions are covered? |
Purpose |
Which training, testing or other uses are permitted? |
Recipients |
Who receives source files, prepared records or derived outputs? |
Duration |
How long can each use continue, and what happens when the agreement ends? |
Further disclosure |
Which sublicences, publication rights and exclusions apply? |
Protection |
What preparation, access controls and evidence are agreed? |
The answers need to fit the actual proposal. A broad label such as “AI licence” should not be allowed to stand in for that detail.
Discuss exclusivity alongside your own future use
Exclusivity can be limited by the material, purpose, recipient group or period. Ask what precisely is exclusive. Different limitations can have very different effects even when they use the same commercial label.
Under the intended licensing model, your data remain your property. Your continued use, the additional rights granted and the possibility of further licensing are matters for the particular contract. Existing commitments to customers or other licensees must also be considered. Exclusivity is not an automatic promise of greater revenue.
Keep sample permission separate from full delivery
A limited sample supports a defined assessment. Authorising that sample does not authorise transfer or use of the entire archive. Scope, purpose, recipient and protection arrangements need to be established before even that limited step.
The licensing process separates the initial description, a possible sample and a later licensing decision. Costs, preparation effort and payment conditions also need agreement: who does the work, when payment becomes due and what delivery or acceptance conditions apply?
Use the checklist to prepare, not to replace review
Rights and confidentiality questions depend on the archive, applicable law and actual agreements. For German material, section 31 of the German Copyright Act addresses the grant of rights of use. It is a reference for that jurisdiction, not a rule that resolves every international licence.